Jillian Segal AO, Australia’s Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism, has released a new document, Combatting Antisemitism: Special Envoy’s Priorities. It targets many of the same institutions identified in her original July 2025 Plan to Combat Antisemitism, including universities, schools, cultural and sporting organisations, and Australia’s public broadcasters.
This time, however, Segal identifies what she considers the underlying problem: “modern, progressive antisemitism”. She argues that progressive activists make antisemitism fashionable by laundering far-left antisemitism and Islamic extremism through the language of social justice and human rights, thereby giving extremist ideologies an apparently acceptable face.
Remarkably, her document provides not one concrete example, footnote or reference to substantiate this sweeping allegation. Readers are simply expected to accept that progressive advocacy for human rights, particularly concerning Gaza and attacks on Palestinians in the West Bank, may be disguising antisemitism.
Segal also argues that negative coverage of the Middle East by the ABC and SBS contributes to the conflation of Australian Jews with the actions of the Israeli government and military.
She reports receiving numerous complaints from the Australian Jewish community about public broadcaster coverage perceived as “disproportionate, misleading or inaccurate”. Yet, once again, the Priorities document provides no specific examples.
Robert Manne, in a recent article in Substack, describes Segal’s report as “the most insidious attack on political free speech in the recent history of Australia”. His analysis can be found HERE.
There was, however, one example of ABC inaccuracy which Segal emphasised in her evidence to the Royal Commission on Antisemitism in July 2026.
On 20 May 2025, the BBC broadcast an interview with senior UN official Tom Fletcher, who claimed that 14,000 babies in Gaza would die within 48 hours unless aid could reach them. By 3 am the following morning, the BBC was reporting that the UN had walked back the claim. Nevertheless, the ABC broadcast Fletcher's original statement later that morning and continued reporting it throughout the day. The qualification did not appear until 4 pm, and the ABC did not fully retract the story for a week.
Segal and counsel assisting the Royal Commission, Richard Lancaster SC, examined this incident in detail during her evidence on 9 July 2026. She used it to demonstrate the ABC's inaccuracy and the negative impression its reporting could create about Israel.
But the detailed chronology presented to the Commission came from the ABC Ombudsman's own investigation. Ombudsman Fiona Cameron had found that the ABC breached its Editorial Policies, and the ABC's Editorial Director, Gavin Fang, subsequently acknowledged to the Commission that the broadcaster had made “a bad mistake”.
In other words, the existing ABC Ombudsman had identified and dealt with the problem. This raises an obvious question: why does Segal want an additional, independent ombudsman?
The ABC Ombudsman has upheld only four complaints out of thousands concerning Middle East coverage, while the independent regulator, the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA), has upheld none.
Segal does not consider whether this suggests that most complaints, from either Jewish or pro-Palestinian audiences, lack merit. Nor does she acknowledge what University of Sydney Professor Terry Flew described to the Commission as the “hostile media effect”: the tendency of people with strong partisan views to perceive balanced reporting as biased against their own position.
Instead, Segal appears determined to change the referee in the hope of obtaining a different result.
Her proposals for monitoring the public broadcasters have also evolved.
In her original July 2025 Plan, she stated that she herself would monitor media organisations to encourage accurate and responsible reporting and prevent the acceptance of false or distorted narratives. Following the Bondi massacre, Segal submitted an Action Plan to the government in January 2026. That document has never been made public, nor have her statements to the Royal Commission. Consequently, the precise proposals remain unclear.
However, in her July 2026 evidence, Segal explained that she had never intended to monitor the broadcasters personally. Rather, she envisaged a structure that would undertake the task.
This apparently involved a committee appointed to monitor ABC and SBS output on an ongoing basis. Commissioner Virginia Bell questioned whether placing such a committee alongside the broadcasters' existing governance arrangements might undermine public trust, particularly if its members had strong ideological commitments.
Segal responded that the committee need not have particular views, provided its members understood modern antisemitism and contemporary forms of hatred.
Her latest Priorities document proposes something different: an independent expert advisory panel, appointed by the Australian Government, ACMA or another independent body, to conduct a retrospective review of public broadcaster news, current affairs and online coverage over a fixed period, focusing on matters that might contribute to antisemitism in Australia.
This is a retreat from continuous monitoring to a review of coverage over a specified period. It also shifts responsibility for appointing the panel away from Segal herself.
Nevertheless, the underlying objective appears unchanged. Segal told the Royal Commission that somebody needed to review the broadcasters' overall reporting of the war because, in her view, it contributed to a new form of antisemitism through conflation. The obvious concern is what happens if an independent review does not support her contention. Would its findings be accepted, or would another review be demanded until the desired conclusion is reached?
Segal is neither an impartial nor an especially careful observer. Her evidence to the Royal Commission, despite her strong criticism of alleged inaccuracies in ABC reporting, reportedly contained several inaccuracies and untruths of its own. These remain uncorrected in the transcript of her testimony.
The government's response last December quietly disregarded the sections of Segal's original Plan dealing with the ABC and SBS. Unless Commissioner Bell endorses her latest proposals, it is possible that they will again be quietly set aside.
That would be welcome. There is a legitimate place for combating antisemitism and addressing genuine failures in media reporting. But accusations of bias and antisemitism must be supported by evidence, not broad assertions about progressive politics, human rights advocacy or critical reporting of Israel.
The continuing suggestion that Australia's public broadcasters are contributing to modern antisemitism simply by reporting on the Middle East is a serious charge. It deserves scrutiny, not unquestioning acceptance.
By Peter Marks, ABC Alumni Board member, based on an article by Board member Jonathan Holmes (with his permission) which can be found HERE
Do you like this page?